Instagram iconInstagram icon
Facebook iconFacebook icon
pinterest iconpinterest icon
YouTube iconYouTube icon
Tiktok iconTiktok icon
LTK iconLTK icon

Going Custom With Our New Dining Table

Our new custom made oak dining table is complete! Today we’re talking through why we went custom (and round!), the process and the beautiful end result.

chairs | ceiling fixture | vase | rug

Our various dining tables have always acted as the de facto command center of our Chicago home. The dining space is in the physical center of the house and acts as a place to gather for meals and also as our home office throughout the day. That said, it gets near-constant use between 9am – 7pm most days, so it needs to be able to stand up to wear and tear and look great doing it.

The view from our Chicago living room looking toward the dining room with our new custom table.
chairs | ceiling fixture | rug | coffee table | shades

Our former dining table served us well for many years. It was durable, comfortable and fit our space well. But times have changed and Lucy has grown into an active preschooler that doesn’t require a high chair or booster seat anymore, so we were ready for an upgrade.

Why Custom?

Prior to making the decision to move forward with a custom table, we scoured the web for months in search of the perfect off-the-shelf piece to meet our needs and compliment our style. This CB2 table was the closest we came to finding the one, but the 45″ diameter would have looked diminutive in our space and wouldn’t be large enough to accommodate even a few additional friends.

The view from our Chicago living room looking toward the dining room with our new custom table.
chairs | ceiling fixture | rug

Since our perfect table didn’t seem to exist, we reached out to our friends at Norman Leigh to discuss (yet another!) custom table. You may remember them as the husband and wife duo behind the custom table in our Michigan Tree House, so we were familiar with their skillset! After discussing plans, options and materials with George and Leigh-Anne, we knew we were in great hands and sent over the deposit for them to get started right away.

The view from our Chicago living room looking toward the dining room with our new custom table.
chairs | ceiling fixture | vase | rug

The custom process obviously required more decision-making than buying from a standard retailer, but it also allowed for an incredible amount of flexibility in size, material and finish. The overall cost was surprisingly not far out of line with buying high-quality standard retail!

We knew we were after a round oak table with a drum base, but we still had lots of decisions to make. We were even able to meet George and Leigh-Anne at the lumber yard to select the exact boards we’d use for the tabletop! Turnaround time on a custom table is also longer that what might be expected from a traditional retailer, but with the production and shipping delays that the world is facing currently, lead time was similar to that of a lot of retailers!

Going Round​​​​​​​

As we mentioned earlier, the dining table serves as the ‘desk’ for our home office setup, but also does traditional duty as a gathering space for meals. We’ve always loved round tables for the way they seem to encourage conversation and collaboration, and we’re always shocked by how many people can fit comfortably around them!

A closeup of the way the tabletop brings out the warmer tones of the rug beneath it.
chair | rug

After utilizing the table every day for a few weeks, we’re thrilled with all of our decisions. The size and shape promote collaboration and screen-sharing throughout our workday and the few times we’ve hosted friends around this beautiful table have resulted in lively, interactive conversations. The round shape really does change how we work and converse around it!

The Process

Designing this table was a truly collaborateive effort. Since we’ve worked with George and Leigh-Anne in the past, we’ve developed a great team attitude when we work together. As we mentioned earlier, every step of the process, including material selection, board layout, final dimensions and even the bevel on the edge of the table (below right) was a thoughtful group decision.

The tabletop boards are glued and joined.
measuring the joined tabletop boards
George routs the edge of the tabletop.
routing the edge of the table

Larger decisions happened in person or on the phone. Quick decisions happened via a group text thread. Leigh-Anne dropped off finish samples when she was in the neighborhood and we observed them in the exact light of our dining room.

Table base take shape 1/4
Table base take shape 3/4
Table base take shape 2/4
Table base take shape 4/4

Leigh-Anne periodically sent along process and teaser photos so we got to track the table’s progress in real time from home. The whole process was incredibly fun and the end result is exactly what we had in mind!

The Finish

When it came time to select a finish, we knew we needed a finish that would offer protection from spills and rings, while enhancing the natural color of the oak as opposed to masking it. George and Leigh-Anne immediately recommended Oil Plus from Rubio Monocoat as the best of the best and we trusted their judgement 100%​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

A closeup of the routed table edge.

After sampling a few shades, we determined that Mist was the best fit for our space. The final product turned out better than we imagined and compliments our space beautifully. After a week or so using coasters and extra care, the finish is completely cured and water and spills simply bead up and wipe away! This finish is truly amazing.

The Seating

Our table is a substantial 62″ across, which could fit 8-10 people comfortably if wedding seating charts on the internet are to be trusted. That said, it’s rare for us to host that many people formally at any given time, so we determined that a total of 6 chairs (with one living in the adjacent guest room, ready to be pulled out as needed) was our best bet.

The new Mazie chairs from Room & Board tuck perfectly under the new table.
chairs | ceiling fixture | vase | rug

We were on the hunt for comfortable, supportive chairs that wouldn’t have our backs aching halfway through our daily work and wouldn’t break the bank. Chairs with arms were topped of our search criteria as well. Kim mentioned this in our IG stories and a thoughtful follower sent over a link to the Mazie chairs from Room & Board.

The new Mazie chairs from Room & Board tuck perfectly under the new table.

We suspected that they were the ones and took a field trip out to our local Room & Board outlet to see them in person. We were immediately convinced! Mazie chairs are constructed of powder coated steel wrapped in wipeable synthetic leather and they couldn’t be more comfortable. The 5 chair configuration is working out well so far and we’ll pull the 6th out from its hiding spot as necessary.

Work + Play​​​​​​​

So far, this table has worked out fantastically for our day-to-day workflow. If Kim needs to show me something on her computer screen, She simply tilts it toward me as opposed to one of us having to get up and walk around to the other side of the table. It makes collaborating easier than ever and we’re both happier when we can make efficient decisions without having to get up out of these comfy chairs!

The new table anchors the dining room space beautifully and acts as a great workspace throughout the day.
chairs | ceiling fixture | vase | rug

We’ve yet to host a large gathering around this beauty, but the few times that we’ve had another small family over, the table has worked out beautifully. The round shape makes passing dishes easy and chatting across the 62″ span is easy and natural!

The new table anchors the dining room space beautifully and acts as a great workspace throughout the day.
A closeup of the table centerpiece.
The new table anchors the dining room space beautifully and acts as a great workspace throughout the day.
chairs | ceiling fixture | vase | faux greenery | rug

If it hasn’t been abundantly transparent so far, we’re incredibly impressed with the way that Norman Leigh carried out our vision. The table is insanely well built and fits our space perfectly. The color, size and scale are all perfect. Now all we need to do is decide if we’ll have our next holiday meal around this table or the other custom table George and Leigh-Anne built for us!

Add a comment...

Your email is never published or shared. Required fields are marked *

  • jenn8.27.21 - 8:34 AM

    Wow, it is truly beautiful. I love everything about it. ReplyCancel

  • Ginger8.27.21 - 9:56 AM

    When we got our new puppy earlier this year, we ended up moving our round kitchen table from the breakfast area (to make room for her playpen) into the dining room. The large rectangular dining table went into the basement as a game/puzzle table. They were both black IKEA Ingatorp tables, just different shapes, so our decor hasn’t had to shift. But really, we are LOVING having the round table in the dining room! It feels like there’s so much more space in the room, we’re not missing the extra seating (no COVID-era gatherings for us) but if necessary, the table extends into an oval to seat at least 6.  So glad to see round tables making a comeback! Yours is gorgeous – we’ll definitely think about something custom when it’s time to upgrade!ReplyCancel

    • Kim8.27.21 - 10:48 AM

      We just had our first friends over for dinner (only 4 of us total, plus our two girls sharing a chair haha), and it was LOVELY. So conversational and the stuff of dreams.ReplyCancel

  • Jennifer Laura Living8.27.21 - 10:01 AM

    It’s a beautiful piece, turned out stunning! ReplyCancel

  • Michelle8.27.21 - 12:33 PM

    I bought a rectangular table second-hand when we moved a few years ago, and it was just a little too big for our dining room. Plus there were daily debates about who would sit next to mom, ha! I found a beautiful round maple table stamped 1962 on Craigslist for $150 and it’s amazing. I’m a big big fan of the shape and everyone gets to sit next to mom!ReplyCancel

  • Sara8.27.21 - 2:01 PM

    This is just gorgeous. Love everything about it.ReplyCancel

  • Danielle8.28.21 - 9:53 AM

    It’s such a beautiful piece! Thanks for sharing the process!ReplyCancel

  • Julie8.30.21 - 1:10 PM

    This is the most beautiful table and I think a round table should be mandatory in every home – the conversations and life around a round table!ReplyCancel

    • Scott8.30.21 - 2:14 PM

      Absolutely! We’ve only had a few guests over, but the conversations are so much more natural!ReplyCancel

  • Chaney9.20.21 - 12:50 PM

    What size rug do you have under your table out of curiosity! I find round tables can be a little tricky to pair with rectangular rugs sometimes!ReplyCancel

    • Kim9.20.21 - 1:49 PM

      We did a standard 8×10 and it’s great! We used to have a custom 8×8 square, but decided to save money this time, and we haven’t looked back.ReplyCancel

  • liz11.10.21 - 4:37 PM

    how does the price compare to a retail shop? can you tell us the price? :DReplyCancel

  • Szymon5.1.23 - 7:35 PM

    What color rug did you pick for under the dining table? I really like the washed-out look of the one you chose!ReplyCancel

    • Scott5.2.23 - 9:29 AM

      It’s this rug. Also, friendly reminder that almost every product source is linked under the photos in the post. :)ReplyCancel

      • Szymon5.2.23 - 10:49 AM

        Oh yes – I saw the link but it went to the Lagoon / Brick 3′-6″ x 5′-6″ Accent Rug, so I figured I’d ask which particular Loloi color you all went with? We got some Loloi samples but wanted to find one that had a more faded look like yours.ReplyCancel

        • Scott5.2.23 - 11:15 AM

          Yup! Confirming that it’s the Lagoon / Brick in our dining room. Hope this helps!ReplyCancel

  • Vanessa11.20.23 - 1:51 PM

    Love!! What type of flowers are on the table?  :)ReplyCancel

Let's be Pen Pals

Our Pen Pals have direct access to first looks, a peek behind-the-scenes, and exclusive interviews showcasing members of the #YBHDIY community. We can’t wait to connect with you!

Kim and Scott

We’re Kim + Scott, Chicago based content creators behind the Home + Lifestyle brand Yellow Brick Home.

Join us as we renovate and nurture vintage homes across Chicago + SW Michigan!

Instagram iconInstagram icon
Facebook iconFacebook icon
pinterest iconpinterest icon
YouTube iconYouTube icon
Tiktok iconTiktok icon
LTK iconLTK icon

LEt's be Pen Pals

Subscribe for first looks, behind-the-scenes, and exclusive community content

/* footer flodesk form */

This site uses affiliate links. We will always disclose sponsored posts in the text and by using the ‘sponsored' tag.

© 2024 Yellow Brick Home. | All Rights Reserved. | PRIVACY POLICY